None of MPs’ eight proposed Brexit alternatives possess secured certain backing in a assortment of votes within the Commons.
The alternatives – which included a customs union with the EU and a referendum on any deal – were supposed to abet fetch a consensus over how to pass away the EU.
Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay mentioned the outcomes bolstered ministers’ look their deal used to be “primarily the most attention-grabbing option”.
The implications capped a day of drama in which Theresa Might perhaps well additionally merely promised to face down as PM if her deal used to be handed.
The prime minister told a assembly of Tory MPs she would leave characteristic of enterprise earlier than deliberate if it guaranteed Parliament’s backing for her withdrawal agreement with the EU.
Her announcement brought on a different of Tory opponents of her deal to signal their backing however the Democratic Unionists urged they’d proceed to oppose the agreement.
MPs hoped Wednesday’s exceptional assortment of “indicative votes” would abet destroy the parliamentary deadlock over Brexit.
The failure to establish a transparent methodology forward ended in offended exchanges within the Commons with critics of the course of asserting it had been “an abject failure”.
Please red meat up your browser to seem this interactive
How MPs voted
- Confirmatory referendum – For: 268 Against: 295
- Customs union – For: 264 Against: 272
- Labour’s Brexit conception – For: 237 Against: 307
- Unusual Market 2.zero – For: 188 Against: 283
- Revoking Article 50 to steer certain of no deal – For: 184 Against: 293
- No-deal exit on 12 April – For: a hundred and sixty Against: four hundred
- Malthouse Thought B – For: 139 Against: 422
- EFTA and EEA membership – For: Sixty 5 Against: 377
The proposal which came closest to commanding majority increase used to be a negative-birthday party conception – tabled by former Conservative chancellor Ken Clarke – for your complete of the UK to join a unusual customs union with the EU to make certain tariff-free commerce after the UK’s exit.
Its supporters included 5 Conservative ministers: Brand Self-discipline, Stephen Hammond, Margot James, Anne Milton and Rory Stewart.
All Conservative MPs – excluding cupboard ministers – were given a free vote, which methodology they were no longer ordered to vote in a particular methodology.
Eight Conservatives voted for a referendum to endorse the deal, the proposal which secured primarily the most affirmative votes. Labour controversially whipped its MPs to support the proposal however 10 shadow ministers abstained and Melanie Onn stop her job to vote in opposition to.
Labour’s possess different conception for Brexit – including “shut alignment” with primarily the most attention-grabbing market and protections for staff’ rights – used to be defeated by 307 votes to 237.
5 other propositions – including backing for a no-deal exit, the so-called Unusual Market 2.zero conception, a separate proposal to live within the European Financial Attach aside and one to cease the Brexit course of by revoking Article 50 – all did now not win the backing of a majority of MPs.
What’s the response been?
Brexiteer Brand Francois mentioned “this attempt and snatch the boom paper” by MPs had failed and the public would possibly perhaps perhaps well be having a survey on “with amazement”.
Nevertheless Conservative MP Sir Oliver Letwin, who oversaw the exceptional course of of indicative votes, mentioned the dearth of a majority for any proposition used to be “disappointing”.
While he mentioned he believed MPs must be allowed to possess one other trudge at reaching a consensus on Monday, he mentioned this would no longer be wanted if the PM’s deal used to be licensed earlier than then.
Self sufficient Group MP Anna Soubry mentioned extra folk had voted for the premise of one other referendum than voted for Mrs Might perhaps well additionally merely’s deal on the two times it had been set aside aside to Parliament.
And Labour MP Dame Margaret Beckett, who set aside aside forward the motion for a confirmatory referendum, mentioned the blueprint had no longer been to establish a single proposition at this stage however to win a approach of the place a compromise would possibly perhaps perhaps merely lie by, in her phrases, “letting a thousand vegetation bloom”.
The prime minister provided to pay the final trace, and trudge away characteristic of enterprise – the grandest of gestures any chief ever really has.
For a second it looked it would possibly perhaps well perhaps perhaps well work and line up the increase she so desperately wants.
Nevertheless within just a few hours her allies in Northern Eire were refusing to unblock the development of Theresa Might perhaps well additionally merely’s most essential mission.
That would possibly perhaps perhaps well no longer be terminal – one cupboard minister told me the PM would possibly perhaps perhaps merely but possess one other trudge at pushing her deal thru Parliament in opposition to the percentages on Friday.
Nevertheless if Thought A fails, Parliament is no longer ready with a transparent Thought B that will perhaps well but prevail.
For our politics, for companies attempting to possess decisions, for all of us, divisions and tensions between and inside of our government – and our Parliament – are too profound to bring this limbo to an cease.
Commons Speaker John Bercow mentioned the course of agreed by the Home allowed for a second stage of debate on Monday and there used to be no motive this must no longer proceed.
While it used to be up to MPs, he mentioned there used to be an working out Wednesday’s blueprint used to be to “shortlist” a different of alternatives earlier than transferring on to bewitch into story the “most neatly-most in model”.
Mr Barclay appealed to MPs to support the PM’s deal “within the national passion” when it returns to the Home for a third time – which would possibly perhaps perhaps well happen as rapidly as Friday.
“The Home has even handed a tall different of alternatives as a methodology forward,” he mentioned.
“And it demonstrates there are no easy alternatives here. There’s no longer any such thing as a easy methodology forward. The deal the federal government has negotiated is a compromise…That is the persona of advanced negotiations.
“The implications of the course of this Home has long past thru this day strengthens our look that the deal the federal government has negotiated is mainly the most attention-grabbing option.”